Perpetual Government Shutdown

The Perpetual Government Shutdown: A  Exploration of a Nation Running on ‘Essential’ Services Alone

Abstract: This piece delves into the hypothetical scenario where the U.S. government operates under a perpetual shutdown, maintaining only ‘essential’ services. By examining the potential benefits and addressing anticipated criticisms, we aim to highlight the absurdity and practicality of such a governance model.​

Introduction

Imagine a United States where Congress, in a rare moment of unanimous agreement, decides to perpetually shut down the federal government, preserving only ‘essential’ services. No more budget battles, no more partisan bickering—just a streamlined government focusing solely on what truly matters. While this notion might seem far-fetched, exploring its implications offers a humorous yet insightful perspective on the current state of governmental affairs.

Pros of a Perpetual Government Shutdown with Only Essential Services

1. Fiscal Responsibility and Budgetary Savings

   Without the need to fund ‘non-essential’ services, the federal budget could see significant reductions. This leaner government approach might lead to decreased national debt and reduced taxpayer burden. Historical data indicates that during past shutdowns, certain expenditures ceased, leading to temporary fiscal savings.

2. Enhanced Efficiency in Government Operations

   Focusing solely on essential services could streamline bureaucratic processes, leading to faster decision-making and implementation. For instance, agencies deemed critical, such as the National Weather Service and parts of NASA, have continued operations during past shutdowns, ensuring public safety and essential research without interruption.

3. Increased Public Appreciation for Government Functions

   With only essential services in operation, citizens might develop a greater appreciation for the critical roles the government plays, such as national defense, air traffic control, and emergency response. This heightened awareness could foster a more informed electorate.

4. Promotion of Private Sector Solutions

   The absence of non-essential government services could encourage private enterprises to fill the void, fostering innovation and competition. For example, during the 2013 shutdown, private entities stepped in to maintain certain public services, showcasing the potential of public-private partnerships.

5. Reduction in Political Gridlock

   A perpetual shutdown eliminates the annual budgetary standoffs, allowing Congress to focus on legislative matters beyond appropriations. This shift could lead to more productive sessions and comprehensive policy discussions.

6. Empowerment of State and Local Governments

   With the federal government limiting its role, state and local governments might assume greater responsibility, leading to more tailored and effective governance that aligns with regional needs.

Refutation of Expected Arguments Against a Perpetual Government Shutdown

1. Economic Disruptions

   Critique: Opponents argue that government shutdowns harm the economy, citing the 2013 shutdown that allegedly took $24 billion out of the economy and reduced GDP growth by 0.6%. ​en.wikipedia.org

   Rebuttal: While short-term disruptions are plausible, a planned and perpetual shutdown would allow markets and industries to adjust accordingly. The private sector’s adaptability could mitigate long-term economic impacts.​

2. Public Inconvenience and Service Gaps

   Critique: The cessation of non-essential services could lead to public inconvenience, such as closed national parks and delayed regulatory approvals.​

   Rebuttal: The definition of ‘non-essential’ is subjective. Services truly vital to public welfare would continue, and the private sector could innovate to provide alternatives for others.​

3. Unemployment and Furloughed Workers

   Critique: A shutdown could result in massive furloughs of federal employees, leading to increased unemployment and economic strain.​vox.com

   Rebuttal: Transition programs and the growth of private sector opportunities could absorb the workforce, promoting a more dynamic employment landscape.​

4. National Security Concerns

   Critique: Reduced government operations might compromise national security and emergency preparedness.​

   Rebuttal: Essential services, by definition, include national defense and emergency response, ensuring that security remains uncompromised.​

5. Erosion of Public Trust in Government

   Critique: A perpetual shutdown could signal governmental dysfunction, eroding public trust.​ AP News

   Rebuttal: On the contrary, a leaner, more efficient government focusing on essential services might restore faith in its efficacy and purpose. ​AP News

Conclusion

While the concept of a perpetual government shutdown, maintaining only essential services, is satirical in nature, it prompts critical reflection on the size, scope, and efficiency of government operations. By examining the potential benefits and addressing common criticisms, we can engage in a broader discussion about optimizing government functions to better serve the public interest.

Scenario Where the Government is Perpetually Shut Down​

Exploring a scenario where the government is perpetually shut down, maintaining only ‘essential’ services, offers a rich vein of satirical observations. Here are 15 humorous takes on such a situation:​

1. Congressional Job Fair: With non-essential services halted, members of Congress might find themselves at job fairs, awkwardly explaining how their previous experience in filibustering qualifies them for customer service roles.​

2. National Parks Privatized: Yellowstone becomes “Geyser World,” complete with corporate sponsorships and a mascot named “Bubblin’ Benny.”​

3. DMV Efficiency: The DMV, now considered non-essential, is replaced by a smartphone app. Wait times drop from hours to nanoseconds, but users nostalgically miss the sticky chairs and outdated magazines.​

4. IRS Bake Sales: To fund operations, the IRS holds nationwide bake sales. Auditors turn pastry chefs, offering “Tax Tarts” and “Deduction Donuts.”​

5. Lobbyists’ Crisis: With fewer officials to influence, lobbyists experience an existential crisis, leading to support groups where they reminisce about the good old days of excessive earmarking.​

6. C-SPAN’s New Content: Lacking live congressional sessions, C-SPAN resorts to broadcasting dramatic readings of the Federal Register, gaining a cult following among insomniacs.​

7. White House Airbnb: To cover maintenance costs, the White House is listed on Airbnb. Guests can stay in the Lincoln Bedroom, but must promise not to issue executive orders in their sleep.​

8. Postal Service Renaissance: With mail delivery deemed non-essential, pigeon breeding becomes a trendy hobby as citizens rediscover the art of carrier pigeons.​

9. Public Reaction: A national poll reveals that 60% of Americans didn’t notice the shutdown, while 30% thought it had been shut down for years, and 10% believed “government” was a new Netflix series.​

10. Emergency Services Overload: Firefighters and police officers, now the face of all government services, are overwhelmed with requests ranging from rescuing cats to fixing Wi-Fi connections.​

11. Education System Overhaul: With the Department of Education closed, parents turn to YouTube tutorials for homeschooling, resulting in a generation proficient in makeup tutorials and unboxing videos.​

12. Infrastructure DIY: Citizens adopt a DIY approach to infrastructure, with neighborhood committees organizing “Pothole Filling Fridays” and bridge-building potlucks.​

13. Economic Boom in Black Markets: Entrepreneurs thrive by offering black-market bureaucratic services, like underground permitting offices and speakeasy-style zoning boards.​

14. State Governments’ Glory: State governors, seizing the opportunity, declare themselves “Supreme Leaders” of their territories, leading to the Great Cheese War between Wisconsin and California.​

15. National Anthem Remix: Artists release a new version of the national anthem titled “Home of the Brave, Land of the Unregulated,” climbing to the top of the charts.

What the Funny People Are Saying…

• “So, the government’s shut down, huh? Only essential services running. I guess that means Congress finally found a way to improve their approval ratings—by not working!” — Ron White

• “What’s the deal with ‘non-essential’ government employees? If they’re non-essential, why are we paying them? It’s like having a lifeguard at the Olympics—nice to have, but really?” — Jerry Seinfeld

• “A perpetual government shutdown? That’s not a crisis; that’s a libertarian’s birthday wish come true. No regulations, no oversight—just you, your bootstraps, and a complete lack of infrastructure. Happy now?” — Jon Stewart

• “I refuse to join any government that would have me as a non-essential employee. If they’re not working, neither am I!” — Groucho Marx

• “You look at this shutdown, and you think, ‘Finally, a diet that works!’ The government’s shedding pounds of bureaucracy like it’s getting ready for swimsuit season.” — Billy Crystal

• “With the government shut down, I guess it’s up to us comedians to provide essential services. Need a passport? Here’s a joke instead. It’s just as useful.” — Adam Sandler

• “The government’s closed, and suddenly everyone’s panicking. Relax! It’s like when your in-laws leave after Thanksgiving—you finally get some peace and quiet.” — Jackie Mason

• “So, the government’s shut down, and people are worried about essential services. Honey, if you think the government’s essential, you’ve clearly never been to the DMV.” — Sarah Silverman

• “A perpetual shutdown? Sounds like the plot of a sitcom where nothing happens—oh wait, that’s just C-SPAN.” — Larry David

• “The government’s shut down, and everyone’s freaking out. Meanwhile, I’m over here like, ‘Welcome to my world!’ I’ve been shutting down unwanted advances since puberty.” — Roseanne Barr

• “So, the government’s shut down, and only essential services are running. Does that include Tinder? Because I need to know if my date tonight is still happening.” — Amy Schumer

• “The government’s shut down, and they’re only keeping essential services. So, Netflix is still running, right? Because that’s all I really need.” — Kevin Hart

The post Perpetual Government Shutdown appeared first on Bohiney News.